First of all I want to say that I was quite flabbergasted by the response to my post a couple of weeks back about "Mel" To be honest, I am flattered that people took the time to even read this blog, much less respond to it. I want to thank you all for your comments, they are quite interesting and helpful. However I feel that if you took the time to write out a comment, it would only be fair that you know more of the details regarding this situation.
The deal with Mel, is that we met under odd circumstances. I dated her sister some time ago. That was how we met. Mel's sister and I never worked out as a couple, and to be fair the break up was beneficial to the both of us. Although I wanted to remain friends after, it just never happened, she went on her separate way, and we rarely even see each other. But during the time I went out with her sister, Mel and I became fast friends. I think it is because we are very similar, and dispite the fact that I broke up with her sister, Mel and I have stayed friends. In fact I would say that our friendship has grown stronger after the break up, strange as it may seem there was less awkwardness after.
We shared a lot of things together. With the other girls I dated, Mel was the sounding board. She was the one that I would go to for advice. And vice versa, when she was dating, she would ask me for advice. The funny thing is it always seemed like we dated in cycles, when I was starting a relationship she was ending one, and when I broke up with some one, she had met someone new. It is only now, that we both are unattached, which may be the reason that this subject of us getting together has came up, the opportunity was never their before.
I guess it is funny that through the years I never even thought about the idea of her and me. The thing is Mel is the diametric opposite of any of the other girls I have been interested in before. Maybe this is shallow or what, but I have this ideal of what I want (or at least what I think I want in a girl) No it is not about looks. I have always tried to find someone who will compliment my personality. I try to give off this air of stoic reasoning. I like to say that I run my life by logic and not emotion. But the fact is I am a romantic at heart. I like doing the sappy romantic things, and I want a girl who fits that model, someone who is a lady. Mel though is not like that, she is a bit of a tomboy.
And that is where the dilemma comes in. All my other relationships have been an unmitigated disaster. So I am now calling in to question my own judgement. If all my relationships failed with the ones that I thought were the perfect fit, perhaps my idea of a fit is wrong. That is why I am contemplating pursuing a relationship with Mel. She is so different that maybe she is right. What I can't get over is that I don't know if I am attracted to her, or am I just grasping at straws. And what is even more scary, what will happen to our friendship? If I go for it and it dosen't work out, will I lose her? If I don't go for it, dispite the fact that she wants to, will I still end up losing her as my friend? Will I miss out on something great? Or am I headed to another disaster? These are the questions that haunt me, and which I must figure out.